Have you ever had swiss cheese? Or perhaps seen it somewhere? We can all agree that swiss cheese has holes. And—intuitively when asked—every hole is only one hole with its two adjacent entrances, and not two separate holes. Nothing unusual about that, right? So, this then begs the question: if we can all agree on the existence of singular holes placed on flat objects, why is there a long standing debate on whether or not a straw has two holes?
While a straw is indeed longer than the thickness of a slice of swiss cheese, the idea is fundamentally the same. There is one continuous hole that goes the entire way through, as a hole is not defined as the openings, but rather the lack of substance in an exposed area.
If a man was shot with a bullet (God forbid), would you consider the injury to be one hole, or two? It doesn’t matter that the bullet has an entrance and an exit, there is only one hole that has been created by the two punctured sides. A straw is essentially the same—a longer, thinner, tunnel, much like the one a train would travel through.
Furthermore, this debate is not one of simple speculation and theoretical imaginings. There is an inherent truth to the description of a straw as only having one hole by English definition. According to the Oxford dictionary, a hole is “hollow place in a solid body or surface,” which tracks with what a straw is. Though the surroundings of a straw are thinner than that of swiss cheese block or tunnel, this would not prove the statement of two holes to be true. If anything, it would redefine the straw as a cylinder with no holes at all, as deconstructed, a straw is simply a rectangle rolled into a cylindrical shape. All we need to prove is that the straw does not have two holes when unravelled to expose its flat form.
Furthermore, this truth can be proven mathematically: Topology, the mathematical study of a geometric objects’ property when it is crumpled, stretched or otherwise modified, identifies a straw as simply a circle when fully compressed. This singular circle is simply the hole identified at the top of the straw, meaning it literally exists as a single hole.
Junior Anshul Dandekar, the president of math club comments, to explain more concisely “topology is an area of mathematics that formalizes the notion of a hole on a manifold or surface,” and that “…if we consider the straw to have some thickness, there exists a smooth bijection or mapping, between the surface of the straw and a surface,” meaning the straw can be interpreted simply as a torus. Furthermore, Anshul explains that “a hole in topology can be formalized as…a class of closed curves that can be deformed into one another…and therefore, a torus has one hole and so does a straw,” elegantly—and mathematically—putting an end to the straw hole debate.
In conclusion, the objective truth is clear: A straw contains only one hole, and any other argument against such a well rounded argument is simply circular and pointless.
