News

Phone ban instated across the District

We all have to deal with the bad experience of having the YONDR pouches. The new policy of banning phones/earbuds that is used across all of SMUHSD is rather inconvenient; however, kids across the rest of the district have to deal with QuietCases: inconvenient signal-blocking cases that students must keep their phones in throughout the duration of the school day. But why is our school using YONDRS while the rest of the schools in our district have QuietCases? 

Everyone knows the process: unlock the YONDR, put your silenced phone in, lock it up, and keep it out of sight. Then at the end of the day you unlock it, simple as that. However, some students leave theirs open since teachers sometimes forget to check or just don’t check at all. 

Students have to do this every single week for every single day of the school year until they graduate. This routine is annoying to some, that students smash their YONDRS on different hard surfaces to try and break open the pouch. This process damages the school’s property, and you have to pay $20 for every damaged YONDR. 

 The school website reads, “on March 26, 2026 the SMUHSD Board of Trustees voted unanimously to implement a District-wide policy banning student use of cell phones for the entire school day also known as a “bell-to-bell” policy starting in the 2026-27 school year.” This sticks out because other schools, namely Aragon & Capuchino, are actually partitioning to get rid of their phone jails–the complete opposite of what the board wants.  There’s a petition going on across SMUHSD, and they so far have 600 out of their intended goal of 10,000 signatures.

But to break down the cost, QuietCases are around $35 and with about 8,900 students in the SMUHSD that turns into about $311,500 on QuietCases this year, not even counting the unlocking magnets and any extras. And with  about 2,100 new freshmen each year that means the district is spending about $73,500 every single year.

When asked about his opinion on the phone policy at SMUHSD Aidan Nguyen, a freshman at Aragon, shared his experience with the phone policy after just 6 weeks of having it,“I think that SMUHSD should lift the phone ban because students already know how to open QuietCases, and those methods and techniques will spread to the next generation of students.” QuietCases were supposed to be the better version of Yondr pouches, but somehow they are worse?! “The cases also block tracking signals. All of that money is going to a system that students already found work arounds to, basically meaning that the system is useless. Teachers also used a system that worked better–[the] rack system” This is significant because the school year has just started and the opinions about QuietCases are already not so good.

When asked some questions about QuietCases Ms. Cervantes, the student services staff, stopped what she was doing, with no time to waste, and she started giving responses. “SMHS has had a nine year relationship with Yondr.” During my first 8 weeks at school I didn’t know that fact, and I don’t even think seniors knew this. Ms.Cervantes also shares, “Yondr gives us a different price quote from the other schools.” Which is a very interesting fact about SMHS.

When asked about her opinion on the phone policy, she stated, “It does help the kids focus more.”As a student I can say that the policy does help students and I focus because, I don’t have a phone, other students do seem to be doing their classwork without any disruptions. She also said, “I personally would have preferred to go with the QuietCases the other schools are using because they are signal free so I think that would be best for our campus.” This is interesting because she said how the school had a nine year relationship with Yondr, but she prefers to go with QuietCases instead.

During our talk on the phone policy, when asked about whether she would want to get rid of the phone policy, Ms. Cervantes stated that she wouldn’t get rid of the phone policy across the SMUHSD because it wouldn’t positively affect the students at SMHS. She also mentioned how she has seen how far the phone policy has brought the students here at SMHS. “I’ve seen the difference that it has made in students and friendships and also the negative impact it used to have when phones were available. We don’t see that as much now”  She mentions how the phone policy is actually helpful because it builds friendship which is significant because people can socialize instead of scrolling on social media for the entire day. I totally agree with Ms. Cervantes, but students, such as myself, would still go the other way, and would want to get rid of the phone policy.

Unfortunately she didn’t have an answer to why we use Yondrs and data blockers at the same time, but maybe that is for us to find out. The phone policy is not the most favorite rule at school, but at least it does good to the students that go to SMUHSD because it creates new opportunities, and gives students time to explore campus, creating lasting memories with friends, and enjoy being outside instead of starring into a screen that can’t help you with socializing.